Skip to main content

There may be good reasons to not like Ballast, but the fact that a "white" director made it should not be one of them

Here's my comment re: SpoutBlog's post Does Ballast Really Deserve a Backlash? In that question lies another question - is it acceptable for a director to make a film about people who belong to another social/ethnic/political/economic/"racial" group? Here's what I said about it:

I don’t see any problem with a person from one group making a work of art/entertainment about a person or people from another social/religious/political/national/ethinic/”race”/whatever group. We (humans) have been doing it for thousands of years. Some do it well, others don’t. But either way, it’s alright to do.

I thought Gandhi was well done - not that I am an expert on the life & times of Gandhi - but, as a movie goer - what I saw & heard seemed like a good reflection of what I knew about Gandhi, even though the movie was made by a non-Indian & “white”, British director. So, it is possible, I think, for a person to make a good movie about a person or a group of people from another group/nation/time, etc.

Back to Ballast: within any large group of people there is a lot of variety in personalities, reactions to the world, etc. It would be impossible to prove that a certain character trait does not exist or has never existed in a given group, as portrayed (sp?) in a movie.
Have not seen Ballast yet. If I end up not liking it, it won’t be for the fact that a “white” director made it even though it’s about “black” people. Say NO to segregation in art making ya’ll.

For the Spout post & all the comments, go here.

- Sujewa

Christmas Eve controversial, fun discussion - 1 of the best American indie filmmakers - Amir Motlagh

Inside the Arthouse ep 2

Full Movie - SNEAK PREVIEW - Cosmic Disco Detective Rene And The Mystery Of Immortal Time Travelers

NEW - COSMIC DISCO DETECTIVE RENE (2023) - TRAILER!

The Secret Society For Slow Romance (2022) - available to rent as a new release starting January 1

Werewolf Ninja Philosopher at Vimeo VOD

Popular Posts

6 Filmmakers Discuss Their Theatrical Movies - Atom Egoyan, Rob Tregenza, Walter Salles, Nora Fingscheidt, Sally Aitken, and Kurt Ravenwood (Hundreds of Beavers) - Inside the Arthouse podcast

 

5 recent full episodes of Inside the Arthouse podcast

  * Related links/ads: 10 Full eps inside the arthouse: 1 - eephus - https://youtu.be/DFGTGOLlLn4?si=2AKwcWZlAEQOtf87 2 - atom agoyan - https://youtu.be/LvsPJ7J4NeY?si=AUdp5-InONQ6c3CQ 3 - ex-husbands - https://youtu.be/Ex4C1wg5vhs?si=rRJ13xcbi7R9nNqa 4 - shorts - https://youtu.be/rRElIGbFKZ0?si=KoGyC7AorpweFnsC 5 - soundtrack coup - https://youtu.be/CgJnNBnTMlE?si=WsL-cw4DGuqrozfT 6 - Walter Salles - https://youtu.be/i7lTDVE2mcM?si=hF5bu-3quwypD6HH 7 - liza Minelli - https://youtu.be/9o3DHw6wksc?si=R5WraD3LGKDyGEfC   8 - every little thing - https://youtu.be/_pbgRGxUWME?si=eDyg3Oao9koo8HPY 9 - vermiglio - https://youtu.be/93HDgIIG5-M?si=iWjBlhDySZ0lBun2 10 - los frikis - https://youtu.be/r5fWv8mrxwA?si=ujDjryJYU2HYfYrm ::

The Genius of Alfred Hitchcock with Director Mark Cousins

  * Full eps inside the arthouse: 1 - eephus -  https://youtu.be/DFGTGOLlLn4?si=2AKwcWZlAEQOtf87 2 - atom agoyan -  https://youtu.be/LvsPJ7J4NeY?si=AUdp5-InONQ6c3CQ 3 - ex-husbands -  https://youtu.be/Ex4C1wg5vhs?si=rRJ13xcbi7R9nNqa 4 - shorts -  https://youtu.be/rRElIGbFKZ0?si=KoGyC7AorpweFnsC 5 - soundtrack coup -  https://youtu.be/CgJnNBnTMlE?si=WsL-cw4DGuqrozfT 6 - Walter Salles -  https://youtu.be/i7lTDVE2mcM?si=hF5bu-3quwypD6HH 7 - liza Minelli -  https://youtu.be/9o3DHw6wksc?si=R5WraD3LGKDyGEfC   8 - every little thing -  https://youtu.be/_pbgRGxUWME?si=eDyg3Oao9koo8HPY 9 - vermiglio -  https://youtu.be/93HDgIIG5-M?si=iWjBlhDySZ0lBun2 10 - los frikis -  https://youtu.be/r5fWv8mrxwA?si=ujDjryJYU2HYfYrm ::

Reading Material

Indie Film Blogger Road Trip