Skip to main content

"What new ideas are forthcoming from mainstream film criticism?" - David Bordwell

While reading stuff re: film criticism I found these two paragraphs in a David Bordwell post re: the new doc For The Love of Movies:

"...What new ideas are forthcoming from mainstream film criticism? In the Q & A Gerry, like the rest of us, couldn’t come up with many. On reflection, I wonder if the rise of academic film studies forced ideas to migrate to the specialized journals and the Routledge monograph. These ideas also had a different ambit—sometimes not particularly focused on cinema, or on aesthetics, or on creative problem-solving.

Of course ideas don’t move on their own. A more concrete way to put this is that bright, conceptually oriented young people who in an earlier era would have become journalistic critics became professors instead. The division of labor, it seems, was to aim Film Studies at an increasingly esoteric elite, and let film reviewers address the masses. It’s an unhappy state of affairs that we still confront: recondite interpretations in the university, snap evaluations in the newspapers. You can also argue that print reviewers, by becoming less idea-driven, paved the way for DIY criticism on the net."

Thoughts?

Read the rest of the article here.

- Sujewa

Christmas Eve controversial, fun discussion - 1 of the best American indie filmmakers - Amir Motlagh

Inside the Arthouse ep 2

Full Movie - SNEAK PREVIEW - Cosmic Disco Detective Rene And The Mystery Of Immortal Time Travelers

NEW - COSMIC DISCO DETECTIVE RENE (2023) - TRAILER!

The Secret Society For Slow Romance (2022) - available to rent as a new release starting January 1

Werewolf Ninja Philosopher at Vimeo VOD

Popular Posts

6 Filmmakers Discuss Their Theatrical Movies - Atom Egoyan, Rob Tregenza, Walter Salles, Nora Fingscheidt, Sally Aitken, and Kurt Ravenwood (Hundreds of Beavers) - Inside the Arthouse podcast

 

5 recent full episodes of Inside the Arthouse podcast

  * Related links/ads: 10 Full eps inside the arthouse: 1 - eephus - https://youtu.be/DFGTGOLlLn4?si=2AKwcWZlAEQOtf87 2 - atom agoyan - https://youtu.be/LvsPJ7J4NeY?si=AUdp5-InONQ6c3CQ 3 - ex-husbands - https://youtu.be/Ex4C1wg5vhs?si=rRJ13xcbi7R9nNqa 4 - shorts - https://youtu.be/rRElIGbFKZ0?si=KoGyC7AorpweFnsC 5 - soundtrack coup - https://youtu.be/CgJnNBnTMlE?si=WsL-cw4DGuqrozfT 6 - Walter Salles - https://youtu.be/i7lTDVE2mcM?si=hF5bu-3quwypD6HH 7 - liza Minelli - https://youtu.be/9o3DHw6wksc?si=R5WraD3LGKDyGEfC   8 - every little thing - https://youtu.be/_pbgRGxUWME?si=eDyg3Oao9koo8HPY 9 - vermiglio - https://youtu.be/93HDgIIG5-M?si=iWjBlhDySZ0lBun2 10 - los frikis - https://youtu.be/r5fWv8mrxwA?si=ujDjryJYU2HYfYrm ::

The Genius of Alfred Hitchcock with Director Mark Cousins

  * Full eps inside the arthouse: 1 - eephus -  https://youtu.be/DFGTGOLlLn4?si=2AKwcWZlAEQOtf87 2 - atom agoyan -  https://youtu.be/LvsPJ7J4NeY?si=AUdp5-InONQ6c3CQ 3 - ex-husbands -  https://youtu.be/Ex4C1wg5vhs?si=rRJ13xcbi7R9nNqa 4 - shorts -  https://youtu.be/rRElIGbFKZ0?si=KoGyC7AorpweFnsC 5 - soundtrack coup -  https://youtu.be/CgJnNBnTMlE?si=WsL-cw4DGuqrozfT 6 - Walter Salles -  https://youtu.be/i7lTDVE2mcM?si=hF5bu-3quwypD6HH 7 - liza Minelli -  https://youtu.be/9o3DHw6wksc?si=R5WraD3LGKDyGEfC   8 - every little thing -  https://youtu.be/_pbgRGxUWME?si=eDyg3Oao9koo8HPY 9 - vermiglio -  https://youtu.be/93HDgIIG5-M?si=iWjBlhDySZ0lBun2 10 - los frikis -  https://youtu.be/r5fWv8mrxwA?si=ujDjryJYU2HYfYrm ::

Reading Material

Indie Film Blogger Road Trip